Haiti and Spiritual Direction by Pastor Joe
We are just a week into the tragedy of Haiti and questions have come my way. For some, I may be too late in answering these but as the events continue to unfold, I hope this may help.
The following is an attempt to give some spiritual direction. My hope is to empower parents who are looking for answers based upon the spiritual questions received from their kids. I also hope to help adults who may be asking the same.
Parents will have either two responses from their kids: 1) Kids who are inquisitive by asking some tough questions; Or, 2) Kids who show no sign of interest simply moving on with life.
I do encourage every parent to talk to your child. If you do not, they will form their own opinions. Perhaps the greatest tragedy is the life that looks upon others suffering and says, “All is well.” You have a wonderful opportunity. Let us not be desensitized to the needs of the world. This generation needs to be aware and be empowered so that they can affect the world for the greater good and ultimately, to honor God.
Some questions for your kids depending on their age:
- What are your thoughts regarding the tragedy in Haiti? Use Google Earth (or a map will do). Show them some photos too. Be advised to filter them. Many photos coming to the States are pictures of corpses.
- What do you think God is doing?
- What do you think the church should do? (What do you think we should do as a family?) I think it is good for the parent to move the child from conversation to action. Think how you can tangibly help these people.
Finally, I must admit. I am not very good at writing when my audience are kids. I struggle speaking to them when they are present at communion. You will mostly likely need to translate my thoughts.
Question #1: Did God cause this earthquake?
By far, I have been asked this question Two options: 1) Either God directly caused the earthquake or, 2) He allowed the earth in its sickness (in its fallenness), to act naturally.
Judgment means that God intervened with the natural world and used it as a a means of punishment –a consequence, to reveal a grave injustice toward him and his law. This is a possible explanation.
Some examples of judgment in the Bible by way of nature: Genesis 6 – The flood. (Noah’s ark is not a cute animal story. God does wipe out the entire planet). Genesis 19:24 –God wipes out Sodom and Gomorrah with fire and hail; Exodus 7:4 –God uses nature (Red Sea) and the angel of death to judge Egypt; 2 Samuel 24:13 –Notice how God gives David options of judgment. Two are of nature. I can list many more here, but a quick look at the book of Revelation tells us the worst is yet to come (Revelation chapter eight).
- I know judgment is a tough subject to talk about with kids. Today’s Christian parent does not want God to come across as “unloving, nor fearsome and certainly not on the ‘freaky’ side”. We do not want to scare our kids about God (so we tell ourselves). As a result, we take stories like Noah’s ark and make them cute. By telling different stories, we reinterpret God. We thus fail as parents to teach the truth about God. Use wisdom as some details can be left out.
- Judgment always reveals that God is king and that he is re-establishing his order. The Bible does not hide God’s anger toward sin. What we also see in the Bible is that God is gracious when executing judgment. He forbears at length before acting. Why judgment? Without God’s intervention, mankind would continue with greater injustices (thus more people get hurt) and then they would never know that there is a God to whom the whole world is accountable. If you take away the judgment passages, you take away the love of God. The best thing for our kids is to know that God is not “cute and cuddly” who sits on our lap. He is king and should be feared.
I will answer the second option after this . . .
Question # 2 Is this earthquake a judgment from God? (Is Pat Robertson right?) We simply do not know. Pat Robertson is playing God when he speaks for him. When we have the Word of God to define a natural disaster and it calls it judgment, this is authoritative. We do not have that authoritative, declared Word of God today. Perhaps in Heaven we will receive a divine interpretation or the whole international Christian community, guided by the Spirit of God, declares it as such. For now, Pat is out of line. (But he also could be right. We just cannot say with authority).
There is an attitude when one develops the Pat Robertson stance. When one says, “God judges them”, they are then left to fill out the reason. Finding sin is not difficult but finding the reason for judgement is arrogant. How can one possibly know? Jesus was asked the same question:
Luke 13:1-5
About this time Jesus was informed that Pilate had murdered some people from Galilee as they were offering sacrifices at the Temple. “Do you think those Galileans were worse sinners than all the other people from Galilee?” Jesus asked. “Is that why they suffered?Not at all! And you will perish, too, unless you repent of your sins and turn to God. And what about the eighteen people who died when the tower in Siloam fell on them? Were they the worst sinners in Jerusalem? No, and I tell you again that unless you repent, you will perish, too.”
The best response when we hear of an international tragedy is to fear God and look upon ourselves with repentance. If Haiti is the judgment of God, this can happen to us too. Jesus’ answer was to protect us from our own self righteousness.
Question #3 If this is not a judgment, then what is it?
God is sovereign which means that he stands over all creation and not one event, not one person, nor any experience is outside his control. If God did not cause this, he at the very least allowed it.
The difference is illustrated: Suppose there is a ball in the backyard. A person can cause it to move simply by kicking it. The other option is that he can allow the wind to move it during a storm. Like this, God is in control of all things, even allowing the earth to move.
If God simply allowed this, then the earthquake is a reminder that we live in a cursed earth. The earth is cursed based upon man’s actions in the third chapter of Genesis. Theologians call this the “Fall.” Paul talks about the Fall in his letter to the church in Rome.
Romans 8:20-22
Against its will, all creation was subjected to God’s curse. But with eager hope, the creation looks forward to the day when it will join God’s children in glorious freedom from death and decay. For we know that all creation has been groaning as in the pains of childbirth right up to the present time.
This “groaning” may include earthquakes. The earth is not right with the creator. We are not right with the Creator. All of these disasters point to the fact that Jesus has not come back to set up his kingdom. While the culture concludes a scientific reason for Haiti, you who know the Biblical story, must give spiritual direction: there is a relationship between the Creator and creation, and all is not well. God is calling man back to him through Jesus.
Why did God allow his church to suffer in Haiti? By far the toughest question for me. What makes this even tougher are the promises of Scripture concerning God’s protection and provision. Just the same, this tragedy hit the unrighteous as well as the righteous.
Because tragedy hits God’s beloved, we may be tempted to think that God is not all good and/or is not all powerful. What about the story of Pharaoh who killed all of Israel’s firstborn? Or Herod who killed the sons born at the time of Jesus’ birth? Even though the sovereign God allows this evil, there is no hint that he is any less powerful and/or good.
One thing is for certain. God looks at life differently. We look at it as something to possess and keep for ourselves. God looks at it to give away. The greatest well-lived life is a sacrifice given to God. I do not say this to somehow lessen the suffering of his kids killed by an earthquake. We as the church do grieve. However, I do know this. In his eternal plan, no life in Jesus dies in vain. All is redeemed. The catastrophe may appear as an accident or as a “tragedy,” but to God he takes his own in his wisdom. Those in Christ suffer in glory. They never die or live in vain.
Question #4: What should our response be? Okay, no kid asked me this. This question came from me. I want to conclude that it is during such crises that the church needs to respond with compassion. This should always be our first step forward even it is God’s judgment is upon a nation. Remember, God judged the surrounding nations for their arrogant reply when Israel was judged. We need to help others and we need to help the local church in Haiti.
One of my all time favorite quotes is from Frederick Buechner. “The place God calls you to is the place where your deep gladness and the world’s deep hunger meet.”
Blue Sky is currently supporting a local church in Haiti through the EFCA. The good news is that the pastor is alive but he has suffered many hardships. You can give and follow this story on the EFCA web site. =
Galatians 6:10
Therefore, whenever we have the opportunity, we should do good to everyone—especially to those in the family of faith.
January 20th, 2010 at 1:09 pm
Donald Miller, author of Blue Like Jazz, comments about Pat Robertson’s remarks.
http://www.relevantmagazine.com/life/current-events/op-ed-blog/19845-don-miller-responds-to-pat-robertson
January 21st, 2010 at 11:55 am
Joe,
Thanks for offering a compassionate, scripture based response. It is so easy to respond to the earthquakes in Haiti emotionally, because of the different things this tragedy elicits in our hearts. Outside of what the bible tells us about the judgement and justice of God, we will never understand on this side of Heaven, or possibly ever.
I really appreciate your heart,
nick.
January 21st, 2010 at 12:27 pm
Thanks Nick! You are too kind. What has been growing in my heart is for Christians to give spiritual direction in light of this tragedy. In other words, we really need to put God in the conversation. The ancients, no matter who they worshipped, would respond to such a tragedy knowing that something is not right with their god. Today, there is a missing link to the Creator as scientists explain only the physical dynamic of an earthquake. These tragedies are signs that not only the earth is sick, but so is humanity. The scary stuff is that mankind is not reading these signs. Imagine how much worse things will get (i.e. the Tribulation) before mankind realizes that God desires justice on earth and that all of mankind needs to turn to him. Christians should be called to pray as well as intelligently discuss that something is not right with the world because we are not right with God.
Blessings to you brother! -Pastor Joe
January 27th, 2010 at 5:22 pm
James Wood for the NY Times slams those who use religion to explain the Haiti events. http://www.nytimes.com/2010/01/24/opinion/24wood.html?scp=1&sq=god%20and%20hard%20place&st=Search
Although the suffering of the innocent is the “soft belly” of Christianity, atheism presents even a greater tragedy –it cannot explain nor give any real hope.
January 27th, 2010 at 11:30 pm
Thank you Joe – for the time you took to write this… it is so helpful to have a thoughtful, thorough response that looks at this tragedy from a Biblical view. Jeremiah and I read it together and were moved by this part specifically:
“One thing is for certain. God looks at life differently. We look at it as something to possess and keep for ourselves. God looks at it to give away. The greatest well-lived life is a sacrifice given to God.”
Might have to quote you there! SOOO good!
May our church experience a revival of this sort… and be ready and willing to give our lives away for Jesus’ sake.
January 29th, 2010 at 3:23 pm
Ran across this verse and wonder about Haiti. Still chewing on this: Was the earthquake an act of mercy?
Isaiah 57:1
Good people pass away;
the godly often die before their time.
But no one seems to care or wonder why.
No one seems to understand
that God is protecting them from the evil to come.